SciMark Report


In addition to archiving DRTV commercials, I also collect industry wisdom. Someday, maybe I’ll publish what I’ve gathered under the title, “The Aphorisms of DRTV.” For now, I present three wise sayings from my collection — two new, one old — using recent projects as examples.

Finishing Touch

Finishing Touch Flawless Brows

Description: An eyebrow trimmer    
Main Pitch: “Hold it like a pencil, use it like an eraser.”
Main Offer: $19.99 for one
Bonus: Free shipping on multiples
Marketer: Ideavillage Products
Rating: 5 out of 5 

“When you discover a hit, run it for all it’s worth.”

The original version of this aphorism comes from Dick Wechsler, founder of Lockard & Wechsler Direct. It can be found in his list of media wisdom known as the “Rules for DRTV Success.” Here, I modify and expand it to say something about the new trend in DRTV brands. While still rare, these brands are deep mines capable of producing multiple hits across several years. Witness the seemingly endless success of Gotham Steel/Red Copper/Copper Chef cookware, or the currently unstoppable Tac and Atomic lines. The Flawless beauty brand has emerged to join them. The original facial hair remover was a monster hit, ending 2017 at No. 3 on the True Top 50. At press time, a second product called Flawless Legs had reached No. 8 on the DRMetrix Weekly Top 40. Now comes this brow product. Each Flawless product is more beautifully designed than the last, and Blue Reef Productions keeps outdoing itself with one stunningly gorgeous commercial after another. In other words, Ideavillage is clearly on the path of running this one for all it’s worth.


Gotham Steel Pancake Bonanza

Gotham Steel Pancake Bonanza

Description: A pancake pan    
Main Pitch: “The fast, easy, and low-fat way to make fluffy, delicious pancakes every day.”
Main Offer: $19.99 for one
Bonus: Waffle Bonanza (just pay P&H)
Marketer: Emson Inc.
Rating: 3 out of 5 

“Beware of chasing ‘Fool’s Gold.’”

Bringing back “Old Gold,” especially with a new twist, is a smart and proven success strategy. But sometimes you end up chasing products that just looked like gold. This one is interesting because it has both characteristics. The original, certified gold was Merchant Media’s Perfect Pancake in 2002. Allstar and Merchant Media brought it back in 2013 and rolled it out again. However, the second time they ended up in a duel with TELEBrands, which had just launched a similar product under the Orgreenic brand (Flip Jack). The result was two campaigns pushed for competitive reasons but that didn’t necessarily have the strong consumer demand of the first time around. This is a common occurrence, as it can often be hard to know how strong a “hit” really is until the retail post mortem. I know of many examples where the marketer in question ended up regretting the decision to roll out. To quote a more well-known aphorism: All that glitters is not gold.


Broadway Beauty

Broadway Beauty

Description: A tabletop vanity mirror    
Main Pitch: “See every detail up close and in just the right light.”
Main Offer: $29.99 for one
Bonus: Second one (just pay a separate fee), lighted compact (free)
Marketer: BulbHead
Rating: 2 out of 5 

“One is an outlier, three is a category.”

The outlier here is Emson’s My Foldaway Mirror, which was on the charts in 2017 but missed the True Top 50 by about 20 spots. Every other attempt has failed, including Ontel’s Flawless Mirror (August 2017), TELEBrands’ My Fab Face (June 2017), and InvenTel’s Mirror Mirror (October 2016). I predict we’ll soon be adding this name to the list. Broaden the category to vanity lights that can be stuck onto existing mirrors, and the number of fails doubles. Indeed, if not for Emson’s quasi-success, I would be declaring this a “Siren” category. It definitely hasn’t presented the three hits that would make it worthy of serious consideration.

What Makes up the SciMark Seven? The PRODUCT should be: (1) needed; (2) targeted; and (3) different. The CATEGORY should be: (4) un-crowded. The COMMERCIAL should be: (5) engaging; (6) motivating; and (7) clear.
© Copyright 2018 SciMark Corp. These reviews represent the opinions of the author. Any inaccuracies are unintentional. To report an inaccuracy or provide other feedback, E-mail: [email protected]. The SciMark Report is also a blog at SciMark Corp. is a firm that specializes in short-form DRTV advertising. For more information and a full description of the S7 scoring system, visit