Response Magazine Site Response Expo Site Direct Response Market Alliance Site Response TV Site Market Research Job Board

 

   Log in
  

The Voice

Nutella Case Speaks to Limits on Scope of Class Actions

6 Mar, 2012 By: Jeffrey Richter, John Waller, Blank Rome LLP


As noted in the December 2011 issue of the DRMA Voice, the marketer of Nutella recently succeeded in substantially limiting the size of the proposed putative class of purchasers of its product by arguing that not everyone in the proposed class had been exposed to the alleged misrepresentation. An equally important lesson to be gleaned from this case is that nationwide marketers who find themselves sued for alleged violations of a single state’s unfair competition laws need not necessarily fear that they will always need to defend their conduct in a nationwide class action based upon that single state’s unfair competition laws.

In the In re Ferrero case, the plaintiffs sought to certify a nationwide class of purchasers of Nutella who had allegedly been exposed to misleading labeling and advertising about the benefits of consuming Nutella. The plaintiffs alleged that the marketer promoted Nutella as being healthy and beneficial to children despite its high levels of fat and sugar.

The named class representatives were all California residents who viewed the advertisements for Nutella in California and thereafter purchased Nutella in California. No doubt seeking to take advantage of California’s consumer-favorable unfair competition laws and desiring to maximize the size of the putative class, the plaintiffs asked the court to certify a nationwide class of purchasers of Nutella and to apply California’s unfair competition laws to the entire class.

Although the court concluded that it was appropriate to certify a class consisting solely of California-based purchasers of Nutella, it refused to certify a nationwide class of purchasers of Nutella notwithstanding that the same advertisements and label were used throughout the United States. The court noted that the plaintiffs made no showing that non-California purchasers saw the allegedly misleading advertising for Nutella in California, purchased Nutella in California, or that their claims arose out of conduct that occurred in California. The court, following established precedent that California’s unfair competition laws embody a presumption that they do not apply to conduct occurring outside of California, concluded that it was not appropriate to apply California’s unfair competition statutes to non-California residents in this case.

Although nationwide marketers may not always be as fortunate as the marketer of Nutella in limiting the scope of the putative classes that they face to consumers located in a single state – and may occasionally desire to resolve all potential claims about their products or the advertising or labeling therefore in a single lawsuit rather than in multiple lawsuits – the Nutella case is a good reminder that even marketers that run the same advertisements nationwide need not always fear that a single state’s laws will be applied to their conduct nationwide. Although the Nutella decision was based upon specific case law interpreting California’s unfair competition statutes, if faced with an attempt by an artful plaintiff to apply one state’s laws to residents of other states, carefully review the applicability of that state’s laws to residents of other states before assuming and accepting that they are correct. 

Jeffrey Richter and John Waller are partners at Los Angeles-based Finestone & Richter. They can be reached at (310) 575-0800, or at jrichter@frlawcorp.com and jwaller@frlawcorp.com.


Add Comment



DRMA Spotlight
DRMA Spotlight: Keeping an Edge     1 Oct, 2014

Article By: Thomas Haire

“We’ve always been innovators in the industry — we’ve disrupted it a few times,” says Rob...More>>


25 Oct, 2014

Berge

October 7, 2014 | Article | By Ellen T. Berge, Gregory J. Sater

The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) has caused indigestion for businesses wanting to... more>>


Waller

October 7, 2014 | Article | By Jeffrey Richter, John Waller

In 1993, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) reluctantly chose not to define what “natural”... more>>


Rothbard

October 7, 2014 | Article | By William I. Rothbard

My last article and others before discussed a new core enforcement strategy at the Federal Trade... more>>


Knowles

September 9, 2014 | Article | By Jeffrey D. Knowles, Leonard L. Gordon

If the beginning of football season were a holiday (and we know it is for some of you), it would... more>>


Rothbard

September 9, 2014 | Article | By William I. Rothbard

We think of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) as an anti-deception agency, and it is just that.... more>>



DRMA-Spotlight_Image_Cannella

October 1, 2014 | Article | By Thomas Haire

“We’ve always been innovators in the industry — we’ve disrupted it a few times,” says Rob... more>>


DRMA-Spotlight_Image_O2

September 1, 2014 | Article | By Thomas Haire

O2 Media is a fully integrated media and television production company, based in Pompano Beach,... more>>


DRMA-Spotlight_Image_GSD

August 1, 2014 | Article | By Thomas Haire

“When Rob Albert and I formed Grand Slam Direct, we didn’t want to be just another production... more>>


DRMA-Spotlight_Image_vantive

July 1, 2014 | Article | By Thomas Haire

Vantiv, based in Symmes Township, Ohio — with offices in Dallas, Houston, Louisville, Tinley... more>>


648350

April 1, 2014 | Article | By Thomas Haire

Higher Power Marketing is a Phoenix-based per-inquiry (PI) advertising agency and Direct Response... more>>



July 23, 2015 | Event

The Direct Response Marketing Alliance (DRMA) hosts its annual Summer Bash each July in Southern... more>>


April 21, 2015 | Event

Join 3,000 direct, digital and data-driven marketing decision makers at the industry’s foremost... more>>


March 9, 2015 | Event

The DRMA's Chicago Networking Party takes place during the International Home + Housewares Show in... more>>



MOY

February 23, 2012 | News

Coming up on its fourth year, the DRMA Marketer of the Year Award is the most coveted award in the... more>>