FTC Loses Contempt Action Against Garden of Life6 Mar, 2012 By: Linda A. Goldstein
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) suffered a striking loss in its efforts to hold Garden of Life, the marketer of various dietary supplements, in contempt of a previous consent order entered into by the company with the FTC in 2006.
The FTC alleged that Garden of Life violated the order by: falsely claiming that its Raw Vitamin C, Raw Calcium and Grow Bone System contained no soy allergens; making baseless claims that its Ocean Kids Omega 3 product has brain boosting powers and other benefits for children; and making unfounded claims that RAW Calcium and Grow Bone System are superior to other calcium supplements. The court ruled that the FTC had failed to prove that any of the challenged claims violated the previous consent order. There are a number of fascinating highlights from the case that should be of interest to every DR marketer.
First, the court expressly stated at the outset of the decision that in order for a defendant to be held in contempt of an order, the order must be clear, definite and unambiguous. While the court did not in this case ultimately need to address the issue of whether the original Garden of Life consent order was sufficiently clear and unambiguous, its warning on this issue is likely to fuel the FTC’s current efforts to move away from the more general “competent and reliable scientific evidence” substantiation standard to a more specific requirement that certain claims be supported by one or more clinical studies.
Secondly, the Court’s analysis of the “no soy allergen” claim should be music to the ears of marketers who routinely rely upon their suppliers for their ingredient claims. Garden of Life defended this claim by arguing that it was not the manufacturer of the product, and that it had been assured by the manufacturer that the product did not contain any allergens. The court agreed with Garden of Life and expressly ruled that the allergen statements, prepared by the manufacturer, constitute “competent and reliable scientific evidence.”
The court’s approach to the Ocean Kids Omega 3 product claims is particularly noteworthy. The FTC will often retain its own experts to critique a defendant’s studies or to contradict the expert opinions upon which a defendant has relied, and the courts have historically given great deference to the FTC’s experts. In this case, the Court ruled that simply because the FTC’s expert disagreed with Garden of Life’s expert on certain aspects of a study’s trial design does not mean that Garden of Life’s expert opinion did not constitute competent and reliable scientific evidence.
Perhaps the most interesting aspect of the case involved the FTC’s challenge to alleged claims by Garden of Life that its Raw Calcium and Grow Bone System offered superior health benefits to other calcium supplements. The court took a very narrow view of the existing consent order. The order provision at issue prohibited Garden of Life from making representations about the “absolute or comparative health benefits of its products.” The court determined that this provision only applied to claims about the health benefits of Garden of Life products or to claims that individuals who use Garden of Life products would achieve certain benefits compared to those who do not use the product. In the court’s view, the FTC’s interpretation of the order provision in question was not a sufficiently tailored interpretation of the injunctive provisions of the consent decree. The court further determined that even if the FTC’s interpretation of the order provision was correct, it had taken Garden of Life’s claims out of context, and the advertising was not making the claims that the FTC had alleged.
This decision will likely have an impact on FTC order provisions in the future, but for those facing initial enforcement actions or contempt proceedings, the court’s analysis and decision certainly provides some useful precedent.
Linda Goldstein is chair of the Advertising, Marketing and Media division of Manatt, Phelps & Phillips LLP, based in the firm’s New York office. She can be reached at (212) 790-4544 or email@example.com.
|DRMA Spotlight: Processing the Right Answers for Clients 1 Mar, 2015|
May 5, 2015 | Article | By Jeffrey D. Knowles, Joshua J. Kaufman
When it comes to fighting counterfeiters, cease-and-desist letters are fine, and Digital Millennium... more>>
May 5, 2015 | Article | By Ana Tagvoryan, Joshua Briones, Yosef Mahmood
During the past year, an uptick in the number of class actions brought for alleged false claims of... more>>
May 5, 2015 | Article | By William I. Rothbard
In “Settle or Fight the FTC: A ‘Hobbesian’ Choice” (July 2012), I wrote that the former... more>>
April 7, 2015 | Article | By William I. Rothbard
In “Does The FTC Have Legal Authority Over Affiliate Networks?” (DRMA Voice, July 2014), I... more>>
April 7, 2015 | Article | By Rachel Hirsch
It is no secret that the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) enjoys flexing its enforcement muscle... more>>
March 1, 2015 | Article | By Thomas Haire
It’s been more than two years since we turned the Direct Response Marketing Alliance (DRMA)... more>>
November 1, 2014 | Article | By Thomas Haire
In January 2013, we turned the Direct Response Marketing Alliance (DRMA) Spotlight on Temecula,... more>>
October 1, 2014 | Article | By Thomas Haire
“We’ve always been innovators in the industry — we’ve disrupted it a few times,” says Rob... more>>
September 1, 2014 | Article | By Thomas Haire
O2 Media is a fully integrated media and television production company, based in Pompano Beach,... more>>
August 1, 2014 | Article | By Thomas Haire
“When Rob Albert and I formed Grand Slam Direct, we didn’t want to be just another production... more>>
April 16, 2015 | File
March 2, 2015 | File
Higher Power Marketing: Conversion Rates So Good They’re (Almost) Unheard Of more>>
February 13, 2015 | File
Higher Power Marketing: We Gave Them the Power to Buy Media in Any Market more>>
December 8, 2014 | File
The Illusion Factory: Interactive Campaigns Supporting the Release of the CW Network’s “The... more>>
August 8, 2014 | File
|Affinity Program Manager - National Federation of Independent Business - Washington, DC|
|The Affinity Program Manager participates in oversight and growth of affinity programs in support of the goals of NFIB?s for-profit subsidiary, Member Services Corporation (MSC), by increasing revenue and enhancing member value. Primary responsibilities include 1) relationship management ? first ...|
|Sales & Service Contact Manager - Actegy Health Inc - Indianapolis, IN|
|Build and manage a high performing Sales & Service Contact functionSky?s the limit ? make this your career crowning achievement! The OpportunityYou have demonstrated success in planning and managing integrated inbound and outbound marketing campaigns ? across telephone, online and social media. ...|
|Senior Director of Marketing - Capital Education - Chicago, IL|
|Capital Education, located in downtown Chicago, is a dynamic company building the model for higher education partnerships by providing online learning services to privately-held small-to-midsize colleges and universities. CapEd supports our partner institutions throughout every phase of the online ...|
|Associate Director-Integrated Marketing, Women's Health - Rodale - New York, NY|
|Rodale is seeking an associate director of integrated marketing to work in our New York-based Marketing Department for Women's Health. The overall goal of the Associate Director position is to write merchandising proposals and marketing presentations that will help attract, maintain and increase ...|
|Senior Vice President, Consumer Marketing & Audience Development - Star Tribune Media Company - Minneapolis, MN|
|Star Tribune Media Company is looking for a Senior Vice President, Consumer Marketing & Audience Development to lead consumer marketing for Star Tribune across digital and print platforms. Reporting to the Publisher, the SVP will provide vision and focus to drive revenue and audience growth across ...|